Brian Grinstead

This is the tenth edition of the XUL/XBL Replacement Newsletter. Since the last edition, we've stopped relying on two major components of the XBL implementation: "in-content" XBL and XBL stylesheets.

Final In-Content XBL Bindings Removed

After recently landing UA Widget alternatives for <marquee>, "plugin problem" UI, and the date / time picker, we don't need to rely on XBL in the content process anymore. This will allow us to improve the security and performance of the content process in Firefox.

It also makes the widgets themselves simpler, since they're implemented with more well-known technologies like frame scripts, JS classes, and Shadow DOM (see the in-tree UA Widget docs for more information). There's DevTools support as well - if you run this command you can see the UA Shadow DOM and <slot> in the Inspector panel:

./mach run 'data:text/html,<marquee>slotted child</marquee>' --devtools --temp-profile --setpref devtools.inspector.showUserAgentShadowRoots=true

The next steps are to enable the UA widget pref by default in release, and then to remove the pref and start tearing out platform support. Barring any unforeseen issues, we expect to enable the pref by default in Firefox 65, and then start removing the feature in a subsequent release.

I'd like to again thank Tim Guan-tin Chien for leading this work, and to the many others who've been involved with planning, reviews, and patches. If you have a look at the metabug and graph tracking the number of bindings, you can see the amount of work involved. It took us on a tour of the DOM via scrollbars, video controls (on desktop and android), input fields (filepickers and datepickers), and even to unexpected places like the little resizer thing inside textareas, XML pretty printing and key handling inside input fields.

Final XBL Stylesheets Migrated to Document Sheets

Back in June, Paolo Amadini announced that we were starting the process of migrating our XBL scoped stylesheets to be standard document-level author sheets. This would allow us to remove an extra unspecified CSS cascade level in the style engine, and make it easier for frontend developers to figure out which rule takes precedence over others based only on the specificity.

This work was broken down into individual bugs per stylesheet to make it easier to track regressions. Paolo, Dão Gottwald, and Tim Nguyen have been pushing this forward over the months. Recently, Dão took this over the finish line by converting some of the more tricky sheets (textbox.css, button.css, and toolbarbutton.css). All of the XBL stylesheets in chrome have now either been removed or ported into widgets.css.

We still have some leftovers to take care of before platform support can be removed (including deleting the preffed off in-content bindings as discussed above), but when we remove support it'll be a significant simplification.

Customizable UI Bindings Removed

It used to be the case that the "Customizable UI" feature, along with many of the toolbars used in the primary browser chrome, required XBL to implement their behavior. Gijs Kruitbosch did a detailed breakdown of the work required to remove this dependency. Most of the bindings were able to be converted into plain JS instead of being attached to DOM nodes. In addition to helping burn down the number of bindings in the browser/ directory, this will give us more control over when to initialize different components during browser startup.

Binding Removals

There are 94 bindings left, compared to 115 from the last update and 300 from the start of the project. Here's a list of changes:

• Tim Guan-tin Chien removed the removed the date-input, time-input, and datetime-input-base bindings by creating a UA widget for input[type=date] and input[type=time].
• Tim removed the 5 (!) marquee bindings by creating a UA widget for <marquee>, after I did some initial untangling by landing HTMLMarqueeElement.
• Tim removed the final in-content binding: pluginProblem by creating a UA widget for it.
• Paolo took on tab scoped notifications, by converting the notification and translationbar bindings to Custom Elements.
• Paolo removed the notificationbox binding by converting it directly to a JS class, which allowed us to remove a layer of DOM between chrome and web content.
• I removed the toolbarpaletteitem binding by updating CSS to remove the anonymous box needed to wrap children nodes.
• I removed the customizableui-toolbar-drag binding by replacing the toolkit/ variation that it was extending with the more simple browser/ version.
• I removed the customizableui-toolbar binding by moving it's code directly into CustomizableUI.jsm.
• Tim Nguyen and I removed the search-one-offs binding by converting it into a Custom Element. Following up on this work, Dão converted it to a plain JS class and loaded it lazily which lets us do less work during DOMContentLoaded.
• Victor Porof removed the treecol, treecol-base, and treecol-image bindings by converting them to a Custom Element.
• Victor removed the treebody binding (which was mapped onto the <treechildren> tag) by converting it to a Custom Element.
• Victor removed the tree-base binding which was only providing a single helper function.